Loaded with danger

The circumstances surrounding Thursday’s accident, involving a steel beam being dislodged from a truck that was transporting it hitting the driver of an oncoming vehicle, are a reminder that road safety is not only about speeding and blood alcohol levels. It is also about good practices being consistently maintained.

Initial reports indicate that at about 11 am Kern Bobb, 33, was driving his company’s vehicle after conducting business at Petrotrin. However, he was injured when the beams of a truck came loose and crashed through the windscreen of the vehicle, striking him on the head.

This incident brought back memories of the freak accident of November 2013 in which a mother of five was hit with steel rods that had been dislodged from a truck transporting them in front of her. That incident was fatal.

Both events underline the need to ensure materials being transported are safely secured.

More and more, our roads are being used to transport large quantities of freight. Daily, ordinary commuters share our transport system with large trucks and other vehicles transporting a range of hazardous materials. We do not have a system that provides for a dedicated lane for trucks.

Drivers of vehicles transporting items have a legal duty to ensure these items are safely stowed. Section 42 of the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Regulations states, “In the case of goods vehicles the load shall be properly secured in such a manner as effectively to prevent the displacement of any portion thereof by the motion of travel.”

This provision, however, is arguably limited to only specific types of vehicles. We may want to look to the legal provisions of other countries that are wider.

In New Zealand, Regulation 246 issued under the Road Traffic Act bans motor vehicles carrying goods which are not safely contained within the body of such vehicle; or securely fastened to such vehicle, and which are not properly protected from being dislodged or spilled from such vehicle. Additionally, nothing is supposed to make contact with the surface of the road, block mirrors, or exceed half the height of the vehicle.

In that country, even persons who are not drivers have duties. The regulations make it clear that operators of a fleet must, “take all reasonable measures to ensure that such motor vehicle is operated on a public road in compliance with the provisions for the loading and transportation of goods as prescribed by or under this Act”.

Accidents involving loads becoming dislodged must be treated with seriously. Not only must the driver be held accountable, but in cases where the driver is employed by a company, that company too should face consequences if any violations occurred.

Normally, if the incident is fatal, then the local law calls for an inquest. Nonetheless, all serious accidents should be probed.

In Trinidad and Tobago we tend to have a laissez-faire attitude to matters of safety. But taking risks on the road potentially affects everyone. The results can be gruesome and tragic.

The work of organisations such as Arrive Alive – which last July celebrated twelve years since its formal incorporation as an NGO – is vital in raising awareness and changing our habits.

The law is an important avenue for redress when things go wrong. In theory, it is also a deterrent. However, tackling the social aspect of this issue that is the most effective guarantee that accidents like last Thursday’s will not recur. This means it is up to drivers to realise just how loaded with danger their vehicles can become. And to take as many steps as possible to make them safe again.

Tobago support for Hurricane Irma relief efforts

The Tobago House of Assembly (THA) says it is leading Tobago’s efforts to provide aid to those Caribbean islands impacted by Hurricane Irma.

Chief among them are Antigua and Barbuda, St Martin, Anguilla, St Bart’s, the British and US Virgin Islands, Haiti and the Dominican Republic.

The THA is therefore asking Tobago residents to donate emergency relief supplies, including non-perishable food items, clothing and financial support to the Tobago Emergency Management Agency (TEMA).

Donations can be dropped off daily between 9 am and 5 pm at TEMA’s headquarters at Fairfield Complex in Scarborough, or at TEMA’s warehouse at Signal Hill; next to the Army Camp.

The THA said the public may also show their support by donating to the Trinidad and Tobago Red Cross Society disaster relief fund account at Republic Bank, Account Number 180482517101.

Several Caribbean islands have been affected by the Hurricane, including Antigua and Barbuda, St Martin, Anguilla, St Bart’s, the British and U.S. Virgin Islands, Haiti and the Dominican Republic.

THA Chief Secretary, Kelvin Charles said, “Being disaster ready should mean not only that we are ready to respond when we face an emergency, but that we can also step forward to assist our neighbours in their time of need. So, we encourage residents to donate what they can, as early as possible, and drop them in to our centres so they can be delivered to those who have been so harshly affected by the passing of Hurricane Irma.”

Anyone seeking further information can call the 211 Hotline. The Caribbean Disaster Emergency Management Agency (CDEMA) is coordinating regional support for those affected by Hurricane Irma. Account details for CDEMA are listed below:

CARIBBEAN DISASTER EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY (CDEMA)

Resilience Way

Lower Estate

St. Michael Barbados

West Indies

Bank Details

Intermediary Bank

Bank: Wells Fargo Bank, NA

SWIFT Code: PNBPUS3NNYC

ABA Routing #: 026 005 092

Bank Address 11 Penn Plaza, 4th Floor, New York, NY

Beneficiary Bank

Bank: CIBC First Caribbean International Bank

Swift Code: FCIBBBBB

Account Number: 2000192003913

Bank Address: Rendezvous, Christ Church, Barbados

For donations being made in US dollars, please use the bank details below:

Name of Account: Caribbean Disaster Emergency Management Agency

Account Number: 1333514

Currency of Account: UNITED STATES DOLLARS

For donations being made in BD dollars, please use the bank details below:

Account Details:

Name of Account: Caribbean Disaster Emergency Management Agency

Account Number: 3666589

Currency of Account: BARBADOS DOLLARS

Young slams Devant on Sandals

Minister in the Office of the Prime Minister Stuart Young yesterday described former minister Devant Maharaj’s complaint about the proposed Sandals Beach Resort in Tobago to the Integrity Commission as unpatriotic and “even traitor-like” from someone who claims to be a patriot. Young told Newsday he saw a report about Maharaj’s complaint and said he found it to be “astonishing.”

The minister said Government has publicly committed from the onset to provide full details about this project. However he said the proposal for the construction of a Sandals resort in Tobago remains at the stage of conversation and no decision has been taken with regards to this project. Young said all that Maharaj is doing is unnecessarily attacking, “a process which is part of a diversification plan” for this country’s economy.

At a post Cabinet news conference at the Diplomatic Centre in St Ann’s on August 17, Young said there will be transparency on whatever agreement is reached to build a Sandals Beach Resort in Tobago. He was optimistic that an announcement on the project would be made soon. In his letter to the Commission, Maharaj alleged that Government had awarded a management contract to Sandals last year. He claimed this was done without any tendering process and Sandals will be, “the recipient of a variety of lucrative concessions.”

Maharaj based all of his information on media reports. He also linked this complaint to the previous complaint which he made to the Commission on the procurement of the Cabo Star and Ocean Flower 2 vessels for the domestic seabridge. The Commission is currently investigating this complaint. Maharaj alleged that in both cases, Government is, “is willing to sacrifice proper procurement process.”

He also claimed Government is using the current economic challenges facing TT as the camouflage to, “short-circuit the procurement process to use procurement by invitation. . Maharaj warned, “If left unexamined, this will set the stage for a dangerous precedent in the procurement practices of the State in the future. Hefurther alleged that in early 2015, then Opposition Leader (now Prime Minister) Dr Keith Rowley spoke with Sandals owner Gordon Butch Stewart about the possibility of a Sandals resort being established in Tobago. Rowley previously indicated that part of the Buccoo Estate in Tobago is the site for the proposed resort.

CAL waives fees for hurricane-related change of travel dates

Hurricanes Irma and Jose have affected people’s travel plans across the region significantly. Recognising this, Caribbean Airlines Limited (CAL) is waiving change fees for customers with confirmed tickets for travel during the period September 5 to October 31, 2017.

In announcing the news; which affected travellers surely welcomed, CAL said extended its “deepest concern and empathy to those affected by the hurricanes in the region, which are impacting our operation, causing several flights to be cancelled.”

Hence CAL’s decision “to minimise inconvenience” by allowing persons whose travel plans are impacted by the hurricanes to rebook without change fees, subject to the four conditions.

“Waiver of all fees for tickets rebooked in the same cabin, for travel up to October 31, 2017; It is mandatory that customers contact CAL before the scheduled date of travel; Full refund of fare paid, for travel up to October 31, 2017. The refund must be requested by September 30, 2017; and All changes must be made through CAL Call Centres or at CAL Ticket Offices,” the airline stated.

It is important to note that these waivers are only applicable to travel to or from specific airports. Namely: the Miami, Orlando and Fort Lauderdale international airports in Florida; the VC Bird International Airport in Antigua, the Princess Juliana International Airport in St. Maarten; and the Lynden Pindling International Airport in Nassau, Bahamas.

Hurricane Irma potentially spawns 'zoonoses'

Hurricane Irma recovery efforts should include keeping track of potential outbreaks of zoonoses; diseases or infections that are naturally transmissible from vertebrate animals to humans.

The warning comes from Dr Makyba Charles-Ayinde, Science Policy Fellow at the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services.

“When we have situations like flooding associated with Hurricane Irma, the water may be contaminated with higher than normal levels of bacterial pathogens, parasites, things like that. Once you have those levels of contamination, we look for it to transfer to the human and animal populations. Since we love living with our animals, we see a more fluid exchange of these diseases between both populations.”

Charles-Ayinde said food-borne zoonoses; such as salmonella and E coli, are another area of concern in the recovery period as people, often unknowingly, consume contaminated food and/or water.

“Fever, vomiting and diarrhoea are the first three tell tale signs of most of those food-borne zoonoses that could result from Irma. So seek medical attention if your symptoms don’t clear up within three to seven days – three days of diarrhoea is bad.”

Charles-Ayinde was speaking with Newsday yesterday on the sidelines of a “The UWI Symposium on Zoonoses: Tuberculosis, Leptospirosis and Yellow Fever – a One Health Approach”, hosted by the Faculty of Medical Sciences, the University of the West Indies at the UWI Teaching and Learning Complex, St Augustine.

Asked why the One Health approach is ideal in reducing the risk of zoonoses outbreaks, Charles-Ayinde said this is because One Health combines information from medical, veterinary and environmental sciences to provide a holistic look at conditions and symptoms in humans and animals alike.

“We believe that you need all three of those domains working together to address a complex problem. If you consider people in silos; you just think about the person but you don’t think about the environment that they live in, you’re missing important parts. That dialogue is critical.”

Charles-Ayinde said conversations should be had about things such as, “Are animals presenting with issues? Are humans presenting with different issues? Are we seeing an increase in a certain concentration of a bacteria in a body of water? Is there flooding or are flood waters contaminated? Are we seeing dead animals?”

“If you don’t share this sort of information, then the problem magnifies before you can come up with an appropriate solution and there could well be a break out of some disease or health crisis. So that cross talk; (which) we advocate under One Health, is extremely important if you want to have a successful approach and a successful outcome after Irma and after Jose,” Charles-Ayinde told Newsday.

Kidnap victim released, no ransom paid

Kidnap victim Clint Beharry, 29, who was snatched from his business place at 11 am on Saturday was released hours later at the Churchill Roosevelt Highway, near the UWI, St Augustine, on Saturday night.

Beharry was at at his business place when four men dressed in police uniform snatched him and took him away.

A TT$100,000 ransom was then demanded for his safe return. Officers of the Anti-Kidnapping Unit under the supervision of Assistant Commissioner of Police Irwin Hackshaw, Acting Senior Superintendent Ajith Persad ASP Rishi Singh and others teamed up with other agencies and steps were taken to rescue the victim. Officers spent several hours on Saturday carrying out investigations and just as police were closing in on the suspects, Beharry was released.

He was taken to a medical institution where he was treated and reunited with his family.

Yesterday footage of the actual kidnapping was posted on social media. In the video, the two kidnappers dressed as police officers were seen running toward the back of the business place, then after a pause, the two “police men”, Beharry and another man dressed in a blue polo shirt were seen passing in the opposite direction. Beharry, dressed in a white vest and a pair of three-quarter pants, was being escorted by gunpoint by one of the men purporting themselves to be police officers, while the second man in police uniform walked at the back of the group, carrying a box under his arm.

Police are searching for two suspects in connection with the incident. Beharry is expected to be interviewed by officers of the Anti-Kidnapping Squad.

TT companies help devastated islands

Efforts by corporations to assist Caribbean islands devastated by Hurricane Irma continue even as they express their sympathies to all who were impacted.

The latest companies – Digicel, bmobile, United Way Trinidad and Tobago (UWTT), and GraceKennedy Money Services (GKMS) – are doing so in ways both big and small for the people of Barbuda, St Martin/St Maarten, St Barthélemy, Anguilla, the US and British Virgin Islands, Turks and Caicos, the Dominican Republic, Haiti, the Bahamas and Cuba.

According to a press release, bmobile partnered with UWTT to raise funds for Hurricane Irma relief efforts via a text-to-donate campaign. bmobile customers can text “help” to 6683 and $5 would be automatically deducted from their account to help rebuild homes and economies. Individuals could donate as many times as they want.

UWTT Community Impact Manager Linda Ramsumir said, “We are excited about using this to connect to the public. It is so important. Money is the most effective input to mobilise and the “Text to Donate” initiative opens up the means for everyone to give. You may think that it’s only big corporations and wealthy individuals who can give, however, by working together every small contribution can make a difference – you can do it through just one text.”

TSTT’s Vice President Marketing, Camille Campbell explained that all contributions would go into a virtual account and when the campaign was closed off, TSTT would issue one cheque for the entire amount collected. Contributors would be informed how much was collected, how it will be used, and which organisations would receive the cheque.

UWTT CEO Jennifer Sancho added that since non-government organisations were collecting basics supplies like food, water, clothing and medicine, they were looking at long-term needs. “We are looking at helping to rebuild communities as well as the immediate post-storm needs. This is going to be a complex and long-term initiative. We’ll identify suitable partners on the ground in the islands who need the most help, and work with them. Of course, this depends on the amount of money collected, so it is important we work collectively.”

Meanwhile, Digicel said it had mobilised over 200 fleets of engineers, technicians and riggers to restore network connection as soon as possible.

In its release on Friday, the company said its response teams were on the ground in affected countries and they continue to work around the clock. It said Digicel was also working with Governments of the region and disaster response agencies to establish the pressing needs of the people so that it can activate accordingly.

Commenting on the Digicel response, Caribbean and Central America CEO, Vanessa Slowey, said, “Equally, we are committed to helping the islands to recover and rebuild in the aftermath of these hurricanes. As we continue to manage the impact of Irma and anticipate the passage of Hurricane Jose swiftly behind it, we would like to assure the people of these islands that we stand with them now – and into the future.”

In addition, GKMS, which includes Western Union, FX Trader, and Bill Express, has decided to allow persons sending money to and from Antigua and Barbuda to do so free of charge as of yesterday.

GKMS also encouraged its customers across the region to download and use the Western Union app to track their remittances and to find their nearest locations.

Horticultural Society of TT elects new executive

Addressing the newly-elected Executive of the Horticultural Society of Trinidad and Tobago (HSTT) at its Annual General Meeting held on Saturday, Minister of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries, Clarence Rambharat offered his congratulations and challenged the Society to apply itself strategically in the year ahead.

Stressing the importance of remaining relevant with the changing times, he cautioned that “success should be measured by relevancy and not longevity,” The Society was also challenged to raise interest in its activities, especially targeting the young generation.

Well-known environmentalist Narine “Gupte” Lutchmedial who is the newly elected President of the HSTT endorsed the comments of Minister Rambharat and assured that the executive will consider them as they plan activities for the upcoming year. “The Minister has indicated that the HSTT can participate in the Farmers’ Market managed by NAMDEVCO and this will be an option to explore as we look at increasing income generation,” said Lutchmedial.

At this time, the HSTT’s flower market which provides an avenue for sale of tropical cut flowers and foliage is based at the Lady Chancellor Headquarters only and the opportunity for expanding into other locations and serving additional clientele is not to be missed, the HSTT executive said.

Lutchmedial is looking forward to work in concert with the immediate Past President Joan Hampton and the other elected members to build on the excellent reputation of the Society. “I am pleased to be involved in this Society which is well-known for winning awards internationally and showcasing our native flowers and foliage at the highly anticipated annual flower show,” Lutchmedial said. He added that his concern for and pride in this country’s native flora and fauna will motivate him to do his best during his tenure.

In addition to Lutchmedial, the other members who will serve on the executive are Joan Hampton – Immediate Past President, Chanardai Ramkissoon — 1st Vice President, Hyacinth Cross — 2nd Vice President, new committee members Kerry-Ann Harrison, Mala Ramnath, Sundar Seecharan, Kimberly Howai and Paul Duval, and continuing members Denise Gobin-Rocke, Melissa Lee Foon, Bertille Sealy, Janice Barnes and Theresa Chasteau.

Agriculture Minister targets farmers’ post-harvest losses

In light of the change in global weather patterns and hurricanes in the Caribbean there are food shortages in some Caribbean islands and in efforts to provide assistance to these neighbouring islands affected by hurricanes, there is a need to decrease post-harvest losses which is hugely impacting farmers locally.

“It is our duty to help them but we can only do this by reducing the amount of losses on the farm due to the damage of crops when they are being harvested or transported,” said the Acting Chief Executive Officer of NAMDEVCO, Debysingh-Persad.

On Saturday, Minister of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries, Clarence Rambharat in collaboration with the National Agricultural Marketing and Development Corporation (NAMDEVCO) distributed over 100 crates to 40 farmers at the NAMDEVCO Chaguanas Farmers’ Market in efforts of reducing post-harvest losses.

Post-harvest losses are losses associated with fresh commodities after they have been harvested. “At the point of harvest there are a number of issues starting –because of improper handling and storage we have hastened deterioration of produce. The way to get around that is to handle the produce properly. NAMDEVCO wants to look at controlled temperatures that will reduce the deterioration rate of produce and by placing the product in receptacles that would keep the produce safe and not cause cracking or compression during transportation to the point of sale,” explained Debysingh-Persad.

One of the mitigation methods is the use of crates. Farmers utilising crates along with proper handling practices and food safety systems would all work towards reducing post-harvest losses. Debysingh-Persad stated that it is NAMDEVCO’s mandate to provide sustainable markets and market practices for farmers and consumers alike as there are a lot of ways produce can be injured while being transported from the farm to the point of sale.

Rambharat said that every initiative his ministry had started has been done in the best interest of farmers, with NAMDEVCO’s expansion projects already underway in Debe and Macoya. “We understand the concerns of farmers especially when it comes to getting your products from the fields to the market. We are also concerned about the change in global weather patterns because our farmers are left exposed, so we want to move towards having a farming system that can withstand the harsh weather and lead to more sustainable farming practices,” said Rambharat at the ministry’s new head office in Chaguanas.

Present at the crate distribution ceremony was the Chairman of the Board of NAMDEVCO, Dennis Ramdeen, Senator Avinash Singh, Nirmalla Debysingh-Persad, the Acting Chief Executive Officer of NAMDEVCO and the Assistant to the Major of the Chaguanas Borough Jagdeo Balroop. Farmers from as far as Rio Claro and Central Trinidad came out in support of the venture.

IDB loans TT US$48M for NCD programme

He was a top muscleman, she runs 17 kilometres a week, and they now are both working to stem the local onslaught of non communicable diseases (NCDs).

Dr Ian Ho A Shu is health specialist at the Inter American Development Bank (IDB) which is loaning US$48.4 million to the Ministry of Health’s Health Services Support Programme (HSSP) run by fellow medic Dr Maryam Abdool-Richards.

The duo in a recent interview at the IDB’s St Clair office told Sunday Newsday how they hoped the money would help save the nation from the health and financial costs of the current upsurge in NCDs.

For this loan, NCDs are listed as cancer, cardio-vascular diseases and diabetes, although elsewhere can also be defined to include the likes of mental illness, said Abdool-Richards.

Briefing notes supplied by Dr Ho A Shu suggest that 80 per cent of all deaths in TT are due to NCDs, whose associated risks are poor diet, alcohol abuse, tobacco use and physical inactivity. Half the adult population of TT are overweight, and TT now has four times as many overweight kids as a decade ago. Childhood obesity is a precursor to adult obesity and poses a heightened risk for cardiovascular diseases, cancers, diabetes, bone and joint problems, sleep apnoea and social problems.

Since 1980 the prevalence of diabetes has increased by 350 per cent, and for each patient on dialysis the health system is paying an extra $136,000 per year. The annual economic burden of all NCDs is $6 billion, or three percent of TT’s GDP.

Ho A Shu said the project will aim to change personal behaviour as early as primary school level. The Healthy Schools TT initiative will encourage more physical activity, plus food preparation guidelines. “We’ll measure BMI from the First Year for a five year period,” he said. Students, parents and teachers will all be involved, effused Ho A Shu.

NCD status is largely related to such as diet, exercise, tobacco and alcohol use, he remarked. “We need to get this message out and measure if it is having an impact. “Traditionally, these programmes are very good at getting the information out, but a gap exists in collecting the results and data.”

Noting the four-fold increase in child obesity, Ho A Shu lamented, “This is the first time in history that the younger generation are unhealthier than the older generation.” He said NCD awareness must constantly be kept in the public eye.

Abdool-Richards said the IDB loan will aim to improve both self-management of NCDs and hospital delivery of care. It will boost the capacity of health providers such as dieticians plus the use of ICT to monitor patients. The loan will fund the screening of pregnant women for diabetes, she added.

Ho A Shu said the loan can help in the upgrade of existing recreation parks and other facilities by the likes of gym equipment to encourage people to exercise more. This funding will be by capital expenditure, but with the Government otherwise to be responsible for recurrent costs such as salaries of sports coaches, he added. Abdool-Richards was glad that the IDB will also be offering its technical expertise to implement aspects of the programme. Even as the programme will enact health ideals espoused by both the United Nations and the Government, she hoped it will become a model of best practice for emulation throughout the Caribbean, where it is the first ever project of this magnitude.

IDB documents show the main allocations of the loan, chiefly US$30 million to the NCDs Prevention and Control Plan, US$8.4 million to the Human Resources for Health Plan, US$5 million for the Health Facilities Investment Management and US$2.1 million for Project Administration. A US$3.5 million counterpart from the Government will fund an e-Health Information Management System.

A Judiciary in disarray (part 1)

Part 1

THERE IS NO gainsaying that an independent and functional Judiciary is seminal to the existence and operation of a democracy. It is the final interpreter of the laws of the country and primarily on such a basis it dispenses justice in disputes between citizen and citizen and citizen and the State.

Its reputation, among other things, rests on the quality of judicial personnel and the objectivity, fairness and impartiality with which justice is administered regardless of the rank, privilege and socio-economic circumstances of litigants.

There is also the imperative that cases before the courts be heard as speedily as possible and judicial decisions announced promptly in keeping with the maxim that justice delayed is justice denied.

In order to carry out its duty properly and maintain its standing and credibility, the Judiciary and, indeed, the administration of justice should enjoy the confidence and respect of the population at large.

In terms of the above criteria, the performance of the Judiciary appears to be wanting. The question for the authorities and the country is what measures can be taken to alleviate the problems confronting the Judiciary in order to improve its performance and reputation.

The fact that the Judiciary is in a fair degree of turmoil is not an issue of recent vintage with the appointment of former Chief Magistrate Marcia Ayers-Caesar as a judge and her subsequent resignation under curious circumstances as well as the conundrum of the 53 part-heard cases over which she had presided as a magistrate. At different times the Judiciary seems to have been embroiled in different challenges which have all affected its reputation and capability.

Twelve years ago in a column in the Sunday Newsday (19/6/2005), I mentioned that one of the assumptions underlying the effective operation of the Westminster model in this country is that there should be “an independent and respected Judiciary.” I stated then:

“With respect to the functioning of the Judiciary in this country, we seem to have arrived at a sorry state of affairs aided and abetted by the actions and agenda of the Executive. The Judiciary is in turmoil and it is characterised by deep- seated animosity and conflicts, whether between the Executive and Judiciary or whether within the Judiciary itself.

“Its independence has been undermined and respect for it has waned. There is public anxiety over the quality of the judicial product. We have had a senior judge acting as Chief Justice advising a political appointee, the Attorney General, to approach the Prime Minister to have the substantive Chief Justice investigated.

“As a result, the mechanism for investigation has been activated. And the latest development which is unprecedented in our history is that a group of judges has actually approached the President to question the application of his discretion to appoint an acting Chief Justice.

“One newspaper has remarked on the judicial crisis as follows: ‘…insiders point to ethnic and political factions, grumblings about appointments to the Bench, infighting and serious concerns about the competence of the Judiciary.’ No doubt, immense damage has been done to the institution.”

Since 2005, there appears to have been little improvement in either the performance of the Judiciary or public confidence in it. The backlog of cases to be heard both by the High Court and the Magistrates’ Courts has increased. The quality of many decisions leaves much to be desired. The unconscionable postponement of cases to unduly facilitate lawyers and the lack of preparedness of prosecution implies that this aspect of the culture of the administration of justice has maintained its virility.

In this scenario of the grave burden on and injustice to litigants, the frequent overseas travel engagements of the current Chief Justice without sufficient justification would appear to be a dereliction of duty.

Building sustainable bridges

An August 24 media release from the Office of the Prime Minister (OPM) sets out five measures designed to improve the air and sea bridge service between Trinidad and Tobago. The measures come out of the August 21 meeting that the PM held in Tobago with a number of people affected by the ongoing inter-island transport difficulties.

First, the Government “has instructed the Port Authority (PATT) to broaden and hasten its search for a suitable replacement passenger ferry.” My understanding is that the Ocean Flower contract was cancelled on August 8 or 9. If so, there should have been no need for such an instruction, announced two weeks later. Shouldn’t PATT have immediately commenced a search for a replacement? Indeed, given the obvious problems surrounding the arrival in TT of the Ocean Flower, shouldn’t precautionary plans have been put in place even before the cancellation?

The OPM release also says that, previously, PATT had “restricted its search and selected a (vessel) under questionable circumstances.” (Not a vote of confidence in PATT.) That “restricted” search ended in the choice of the Ocean Flower. To what, and why, was it “restricted?” What were the “questionable circumstances?” But I imagine that, for answers to these and other concerns, we have to await the results of the various investigations now underway.

Second, the Government has decided to buy a “brand-new ferry.” Is it really necessary, I wonder, for the State to own a ferry? What are the economic and developmental arguments for such ownership? What, for instance, is the fit, if any, with plans for the growth of the marine sector? What could be the role of private enterprise?

Third, we are told that the PM “believes, given Tobago’s reliance on the ferry for sustenance, that the service should be operated out of Tobago and under the guidance of Tobago.” I’m not sure that your reliance on something logically suggests you should operate and guide that thing, but let that pass for now.

However, there’s the 1996 Tobago House of Assembly Act, about the “powers” in whose Fifth Schedule successive Tobago politicians have consistently bragged, and which confers on the THA the responsibility — circumscribed, I agree — for air and sea transportation. Why then would one have to say in 2017 that Tobago should be granted a right it has allegedly possessed for the last 20-odd years? You understand why I’ve always maintained that the 1996 legislation is nothing more than a political will-o’-the-wisp?

I have no problem with the concept and principle enunciated by the PM, but is the required infrastructure, human and material, in place in Tobago? I don’t know; I only ask. I have, for example, the CV of a Tobagonian who claims qualifications in port management and business administration, and who tells me he has found that his job applications always disappear from PATT’s files. Why would that happen?

Fourth, the release says that “PATT’s board will be expanded to give more Tobagonians a seat at the table.

The board currently has one representative from the island, and this is to be increased to three.” Section 3(2) of the Port Authority Act states that “the Authority” (ie, the board) “shall consist of no fewer than five nor more than nine persons … Of these persons, five shall be appointed from amongst persons who have special qualifications in, and have had experience of, matters relating to engineering, accountancy, law, economics or business management.”

According to the PATT website, the current board has seven members, so the addition of two people would take it to its full legally permitted complement. Whatever benefits the two new appointees may bring, I hope that at least five members of the present board satisfy the listed professional and experience criteria. Is that the case?

The fifth measure is a forthcoming Cabinet decision on Caribbean Airlines’ booking policy. According to the PM, “(w)e are operating a system where people can book at will and cancel at will without penalty… (S)eats … made available by CAL (must) give the best opportunity for nationals to travel.”

The PM is perfectly correct. You have visitors to Tobago who book several return flights to Trinidad but turn up only for the last-booked because “de lime was goin’ good.” No penalty attaches to this selfishness, which inconveniences others — a manifestation of our usual lack of responsibility — and it is more than time that sanctions were introduced and applied.

This is a matter I recall discussing aeons ago when, in BWIA days, I was chairman of the government’s Air Services Negotiating Committee. I cannot understand why in 2017 the practice continues unpunished.

One last word. Devant Maharaj has asked the President to intervene in the sea bridge issue. I suggest Maharaj reads section 80(1) of the Constitution.

Hate attacks on elderly women

I am trying to understand what is happening in Trinidad. It is not simply that there is spiralling violence and increasing discontent. It is not even that there is a form of hubris that makes us think that God is a Trini and that hurricanes may wreak havoc and disaster on other Caribbean shores but we remain inviolate.

It is not even that some in our nation actually blame the current extraordinary spate of storms on the fact that we have people who are gay in our midst (believe it or not). What I find increasingly difficult to understand is the current aggression against elderly women.

This mounting violence and even hatred against older women suggests two things: first an unreasoning rancour against those who may be seen to have in some way laid the groundwork for the development of the nation and may therefore be blamed for our current situation. This is obviously irrational, but we all know that women and mothers are often blamed for what happens to the generations that come after them. It is one of the ways that patriarchy absolves itself.

There may also be a building resentment levelled at women who are now seen to be fast overtaking men in business, the professions and academia. We know that for whatever reason, young women in particular are excelling in areas hitherto dominated by men and boys.

This is not the fault of the women and the girls. Perhaps we need to look more closely at how our young men are taught to regard the females in their lives.

But there is perhaps more to it than this. About a year ago I interviewed a Trinidadian psychiatrist who claimed that the biggest problem that we face as a people is our inability to say thank you to the past. We prefer to hate it and ourselves. In other words the past and those who have helped to shape it have become burdens.

If one thinks about it, the women who have in recent times borne the brunt of irrational violence are those who came of age during the birth of our nation. In a sense, these women are the mothers of our Caribbean State.

This suggests that we may perhaps not be able to accept the value of those who have shaped us. But this really derives from our inability to accept responsibility for our own actions. We know that there are neurotics who actually begin to hate those who have shaped them and who, because they feel indebted and cannot tolerate this sense of indebtedness, turn their feelings around and into a symphony of blame against those very individuals who made them who they are. Is this at the core of our present spate of attacks on elderly women?

I was particularly appalled at the murders of Dr Claire Broadbridge and Ramdevi Singh. But I also remembered the two women whose bodies were found in Siparia around Carnival time. They were pillars of society.

I have no idea if my analysis is correct. What I do know is that women who came of age in the sixties and who are now having their throats cut and their bodies stripped of clothing or who are being exposed to other indignities have become symbols in my mind of that sense of self-hatred that, I think, is at the heart of our diseased State.

There has to be a reason why those who have contributed to our society are now becoming subject to a level of humiliation and anger that we have never before experienced.

ACS Secretary General: Rapid response will save many lives

Despite its economic and political problems, Venezuela is taking the lead in providing assistance to the government of Antigua where it is helping with the evacuation of people from its sister island, Barbuda, where 95 percent of the buildings are said to have been destroyed by Hurricane Irma.

This was revealed Friday by Secretary General of the Association of Caribbean States (ACS) Dr June Soomer as she addressed the opening ceremony of the 26th Meeting of the Special Committee for Transport held at the ACS Secretariat, Sweet Briar Road, St.Clair. Soomer said that up to Friday morning, aircraft left Venezuela for St Lucia to collect supplies for Antigua and Barbuda. She said the Cuban government is also sending a group of technical people to the region although Cuba has also been affected by the hurricane.

She said that the prime minister of St Lucia is coordinating efforts to provide relief to the countries ravaged by Hurricane Irma and specifically asked that the countries of the ACS be involved in the relief efforts.

Soomer said that ACS member states Mexico and Guatemala have suffered major earthquakes, in the case of Mexico it was the biggest earthquake to hit the country since 1985, and there are tsunami warnings for all the countries in Central America: Panama, Mexico, Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, Nicaragua and Costa Rica. “And so our prayers are with them also as they are with the people of the region who have gone through this disaster caused by Hurricane Irma and quickly to be followed by Jose.”

She said that St Maarten, an associate member state of the ACS is also under severe pressure and will receive assistance from Cuba as well.

She said that while the rapid response to the disaster will save a lot of lives, “I am always concerned about the post-disaster period because it is a time when there are lots of debris and so we have to work also with these countries to help them to clean up very quickly and return to normalcy.” She said the Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) is doing “a tremendous job” in helping with relief efforts and commended the organisation for its assistance, adding that the ACS looks forward to continuing to help all its member states and associate member states in their time of need. Soomer said the ACS was also assisting countries which are not even members of the organisation, such as the British Virgin Islands (BVI) which suffered “tremendous loss”. She said that although the BVI will be getting help from the British Government, the territory is one of “our sister countries and we want to help.”

Also addressing the opening ceremony was this country’s Minister of Works and Transport, Rohan Sinanan, who said that while each of the islands of the Caribbean spend huge sums of money promoting tourism, they can gain much more if they commit themselves to developing and strengthening travel in the region, including making interisland movement and trade cheaper, more easily accessible and more enjoyable by providing a better service.

Leisure reading that gives a lift

Today I feature books that exercise your brain. At the end of a long day, everyone needs a relaxing book that will also stimulate learning. Students are no exception.

Reading helps to build the skills students need to succeed in school and in life. Students also need books that will entertain and offer an escape from the pressures of their academic lives.

So, here’s the perfect end of the day and back-to-school leisure reading list for everyone. It features some of my favourite books that offer what I like to call a reading lift.

The Beguiled by Thomas Cullinan – The Beguiled offers a tense story of deceit from multiple point of views. When a young student from the Miss Martha Farnsworth Seminary for Young Ladies brings a wounded Union soldier to the school, the Southern, Confederate women and girls smother him with charm. As the young soldier abuses their feelings, the girls’ goodwill takes an unexpected turn that causes everyone to fight for their lives.

Hidden Figures by Margot Lee Shetterly – The inspiring story of the Afro-American women who worked for NASA during the early days of the US space programme is a must-read, inspirational biography/history for girls who study science and math.

Green Days by the River by Michael Anthony – Students are in for a big treat when Michael Anthony’s Green Days by the River opens in MovieTowne on September 27. This novel about a teenage boy trying to find his place in a new village is a timeless Trinidad classic because of the astute way in which Anthony deals with relationships and Shell’s dilemma about which of the two girls he will choose.

Paper Towns by John Green – Reluctant readers who wish to take a literary plunge can’t go wrong with a John Green, Young Adult (YA) novel. Here, a popular teenager girl runs away from home and leaves clues for the nerd next door to find her. Green presents a fun-filled mystery wrapped in a story about teen relationships.

The Gunslinger by Stephen King – Stephen King loosely based his Dark Tower series on the French classic The Song of Roland so that gives this fantasy/alternative world thriller some important clout. Once again, students will learn how easy it is to build reading speed, comprehension and analytical skills while reading an entertaining novel. Talk about an escape. This book allows readers to escape to a parallel world where good vs evil at every turn.

Will’s Red Coat: The Story of One Old Dog Who Chose to Love Again by Tom Ryan – If you want a heart-warming, inspirational, non-fiction book, try Will’s Red Coat, the story of a blind, deaf and partly-crippled dog rescued by the author. Will’s story, first featured in a blog, had thousands of followers.

The Promise by Robert Crais – An action-packed detective story can be the perfect skill-building escape at the end of a long school day. When it comes to delivering a tense tale, The Promise never disappoints. Here, Los Angeles police officer Scott James fights his way back from an injury and the ambush of his police partner with Maggie, a marine dog who is traumatised after she loses her handler. You will also want to read The Suspect, a sequel to The Promise.

Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Koreans by Barbara Demick – Through interviews with North Koreans who made daring escapes to live in South Korea, Demick presents a brilliant piece of journalism that presents the horrors of North Korea, a country that is in always in the news.

Happy reading!

Next week:

Look out for the 2016 Bocas Literature Festival-winning books.

Trade unions have duty to protect jobs

THE EDITOR: I read with interest a letter by Lynette Joseph, titled “Butler would say move forward and reinvent.” Let me say from the beginning that Joseph makes some useful points but I respectfully disagree with some of her postulations.

The idea of reinvention is a principle which has been used in the main by commercial organisations within the process of strategic planning. The term used internationally as it applies to trade unions is “revitalisation” on which a number of items of literature exist pertaining to various international labour federations.

My point of departure is while trade unions have to and have been employing new tools, this cannot and should not be at the expense of the old tried and tested tools employed by the trade union movement.

Joseph needs to realise that there are different models of trade unions and it is among those who have been employing the agency model and the Fosterite approach that the accommodation has been made to accept a business model which exposes the union to all kinds of criticism. Trade unions that have adopted the organising model and the Butlerite approach have not adopted the posture and attitude which seems to have offended Joseph.

Joseph needs to realise that not because “people can vote” there is an excuse to vary the real mission of the trade union movement. The level of inequality, inclusive of income inequality which exists in TT, is entirely unacceptable. There is no “state of collapse of local and foreign financial institutions.” Despite the financial crisis, financial institutions have returned to their ivory tower positions of privilege in the society.

No measure of attitudinal change can be used to justify retrenchment. Retrenchment without adequate social security is a recipe for social disaster due to reduction of purchasing power and a tailspin into the abyss of recession.

Trade unions do not exist to merely administrate over retrenchment exercises. We have a duty to protect jobs and I dare say that if Comrade Uriah Butler was alive he would stand firmly with the leaders of the trade union movement.

As our LEAP presentation declares, we have to grow out of the crisis. Jobless growth defies any concept of real development. The economic approach that it is inevitable that workers will be retrenched is an outdated model. We need to keep workers employed and not put a further burden on the State and taxpayers who inevitably would have to support the unemployed.

VINCENT

CABRERA

via email

Maracas Beach still same way

THE EDITOR: It has been about two months since an allocation of $60 million was announced for the development of Maracas Beach. However, there has been no change.

Visitors to Maracas, including tourists, are finding an environment that leaves a lot to be desired. Those incomplete structures are still there, with stagnant water that at times gives off a foul smell accumulating in them. The car park is in need of repaving and the environs generally can do with an upliftment to add beauty to the place.

If we are serious about attracting visitors to our country, Maracas Beach just simply cannot continue looking rundown and unattractive. People actually come to Trinidad to visit this beach to relax and of course for the bake and shark. It leaves me to wonder if we are really serious about tourism. If we are, let it be reflected at Maracas.

If the $60 million allocated is there, let us make use of it. We can also get the business sector involved. Either way we must do something about Maracas.

ARNOLD

GOPEESINGH

via email

Green Days brings it home

If you grew up in Trinidad and Tobago, you probably have fond memories of Green Days by the River, one of Michael Anthony’s classic novels of a local childhood (along with The Games Were Coming and The Year in San Fernando).

Now it’s been filmed by local director Michael Mooleedhar, and selected to open this year’s Trinidad + Tobago film festival (ttff), which also opened with a TT-made film last year, a sign of progress and higher standards being attained in the local industry. The script, by Dawn Cumberbatch, deftly captures the novel, beginning with its powerful opening evocation of the rich flora and fauna and other images of life in rural Trinidad: mangrove, scarlet ibis, fishermen pulling seine.

As in the book, though, this is a dangerous beauty. Even the bush of rural Mayaro half a century ago conceals some sharp thorns and venomous creatures, some of them with only two legs. There may be no guns, or traffic, or oil rigs, but life there is less idyllic than it seems, said a media release.

The protagonist, the teenage Shellie “Shell” Lammy (Sudai Tafari) must undergo the rites of passage from youth to manhood, and finds along the way that some of them can only be endured with great pain.

For one thing, the little Lammy family has moved to an agricultural area of Mayaro from “down the beach” because his mother had to get a job there, now his father is too ill to work.

Christine knocks criticisms as PATT chairman

Days after being chastised over the quality of her leadership at the Port Authority of Trinidad and Tobago (PATT), former chairman Christine Sahadeo has hit back, insisting the accusations were both unfair and unfounded.

Further, Sahadeo told Sunday Newsday the accusations levelled against her by former board member Ferdie Ferreira and current acting CEO Charmaine Lewis appeared to be in breach of the tenets of the Parliament’s Joint Select Committee (JSC), which began its enquiry into the operations of the inter-island seabridge, last week, at the International Waterfront Complex, Port-of-Spain.

She made it clear that the views expressed by Ferreira and Lewis about the conduct of stewardship were not the opinions of the entire board. Sahadeo also said the “principled” stances she adopted during her tenure were in keeping with her knowledge of the shipping industry and in the best interest of Trinidad and Tobago.

So concerned is Sahadeo about the accusations made about her conduct, she said she intends to re-appear before the JSC when it resumes on or after September 18, to set the record straight on several issues. The former PATT chairman said she did not wish to smear anyone’s character but felt she needed to clear their air on several matters raised by Ferreira and Lewis.

The JSC’s enquiry, headed by Independent Senator Stephen Creese, is one of four probes currently taking place into the sea bridge after concerns were raised, weeks ago, about the procurement of the Cabo Star and Ocean Flower 2 vessels, both of which were supplied by the Canada-based Bridgemans Services Group.

Enquiries are being carried out also by the PATT, Integrity Commission and businessman Christian Mouttet, who was retained by the Government to conduct an independent investigation into the acquisition of the ferries.

Mouttet is expected to present his report to Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley in about one week.

At the start of the Land and Physical Infrastructure JSC on Monday, Sahadeo faced stiff criticism from Ferreira, a People’s National Movement founding member who served as a commissioner during her term as PATT chairman.

He accused her of questionable conduct and creating “serious internal conflicts” within the former board. Ferreira said he even went so far as to write to the PNM about Sahadeo’s conduct.

Lewis said subsequently there had been “a lot of interference” under Sahadeo’s watch, particularly in relation to her decision to use Kallco for maintenance dredging at the port, even though management had disagreed. She had also accused Sahadeo of changing minutes and acting as an executive chairman.

But in a Sunday Newsday interview at the St Augustine campus of the University of the West Indies where she works as a senior lecturer in the Department of Management Studies, Sahadeo said apart from being unfair, the statements made against her at the JSC’s sittings appeared to contravene its terms of reference.

In fact, she singled out JSC member Nigel De Freitas, whom she said, felt it was not fair to allow comments to be made against her in her absence. “I thought that is really how it should have been managed, firstly, not to allow it because much of the banter that went on is not part of what the terms of reference of the committee is because I was asked, ‘Why I resigned?’ I don’t think that was a remit of the committee.”

She said given the nature of such public hearings “we need to be more careful in how we tread waters, because we were not summoned. We were invited to attend and therefore, I imagine you should treat your guests appropriately.”

A former minister in the Ministry of Finance during the Patrick Manning administration, where she served for five years, Sahadeo also had extensive experience in the corporate sector.

She was on various boards within the Neal & Massy group, and is a chartered accountant and practising attorney. Sahadeo also has worked as an external auditor and as an assistant to the Inspector of Banks.

She was appointed PATT chairman in September 2015 but resigned some 17 months later, in February 2017.

It was reported she had left because of the huge workload at the port and could not dedicate the time required to perform the job efficiently. But Sahadeo told Sunday Newsday it had become too “tiring” dealing with certain members of the board.

She again took issue with the tone of the JSC, saying: “I don’t think it’s fair because you have parliamentary privilege. People have taken advantage of it and I believe it is the Chair’s responsibility to make sure that questions asked are relevant to the issues at hand.”

The former PATT chairman added: “I believe that some of the issues and matters that have been raised, I am not quite sure of the relevance to the issues before us. Respectfully so, because I am saying it is an abuse in some in stances. People have used it as a forum for really it being a soap box.”

On the investigations into the procurement of the Cabo Star and Ocean Flower 2, Sahadeo said she did not wish to pre-empt the outcome of such probes by offering an opinion.

“I think each one gets a life of its own.” However, she said she hoped some consensus would be arrived at in moving the process to acquire vessels forward in the best interest of country. Sahadeo said acquiring proper vessels to service the inter-island route should not be a difficult process.

“But you must get the right configuration of the vessels,” she said.

Time to make port profitable

Sahadeo said in mulling over the operations of the sea bridge to make it more commercially viable, the board had recommended the implementation of a penal system for customers who cancel their tickets outside of a certain time period.

“Because what you had happening is that they would say the vessel is full and then you have a no show of 20 per cent (customers) if not more sometimes. So that was one of a small area but sizeable, and to me it would make it more efficient.”

Saying there was need to generate revenue to enable the Port Authority to be more self-sustaining “to a point,” Sahadeo said catering should not be a cost, but a revenue, “because you could outsource it. People pay for it and therefore, it should be a revenue item.”

She added: “Costs need to be looked at critically because I don’t think we looked at costs clinically enough. We also did not take time to differentiate the cost of moving cargo in terms of private, personal and commercial.

“We know we want to maintain the cost of living in Tobago but still feel the private entrepreneurs were getting away with a lot of very low subsidised costs.

“We subsidise a lot of other areas at the port. I don’t know if everybody is aware of some of these areas which the Government should not be subsidising.”

Alluding to the economic downturn, Sahadeo said the time has come for Government to quickly re-evaluate the operations of the port with a view to making it more profitable.

“Government just does not have the money and, therefore, we have to make sure that all our activities, as best as possible, should be self-financing.

“I agree that we have always had a subsidy on the cost of the sea bridge. But the question is, “If we give private people, allow private entrepreneurs to ply the service, would that competition allow us to be more successful? It is a question that needs to be asked.”

Sahadeo said there have been occasions when fewer than 20 people were on sailings. “It costs $100,000 in gasoline to go to Tobago. I believe we need to make a decision and pay the difference for them to fly.” She said efficiency also would redound to having the right size of vessel. “Because a vessel that is too small will not be able to serve the people of Trinidad and Tobago, but one which is in excess of our capacity is costly to operate and has a substantial drain on our resources.”

Moving ahead and in the interest of accountability, Sahadeo said there must be a rewards system.

“I believe we should reward people for good work but similarly if you cannot do the job, that should also be dealt with.”

Saunders quits as coach of Central FC

Dale Saunders, the former national defensive midfielder, has quit his role as coach of TT Pro League champions Central FC.

Saunders, who also held a coaching role at the now defunct Joe Public, replaced current Trinidad and Tobago’s goalkeeping coach Ross Russell at the helm of Central FC in December 2015.

But Stern John, another member of the national men’s team technical staff, was seen giving instructions during Friday’s Pro League encounter between Central FC and North East Stars at the Arima Velodrome, while rumours were abound that Saunders had parted ways with the three-time Pro League kings.

Contacted for a comment yesterday, the 43-year-old Saunders admitted, “The rumour is out. I’m not with Central FC anymore. They had some outstanding payments and stuff.

“I made a decision to leave the club. I think I had enough. It’s time for me to move on. And I have some things happening right now.”

Asked to elaborate on what he has planned for the future, Saunders replied, “Some things on my own initiative.”

During the past few months (after Central FC completed a Pro League three-peat), a slew of players have either left the club or signalled their intentions to move on, due to the financial struggles at the Brent Sancho-owned club.

Among the players who have left are Jan-Michael Williams, Keron Cummings, Rundell Winchester, Julius James, Keion Goodridge, Darren Mitchell, Marcus Joseph, Kevon Villaroel, Willis Plaza, Leston Paul and Carlos Edwards, as well as the Antiguan pair of Vashami Allen and Walter Prince.

John now becomes the sixth official coach at the club, in its five-year-long existence.

The previous coaches at Central FC were Englishmen Graham Rix and Terry Fenwick, Zoran Vranes of Serbia, Russell and Saunders.